Current:Home > ContactPhiladelphia man won’t be retried in shooting that sent him to prison for 12 years at 17--DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews Insights
Philadelphia man won’t be retried in shooting that sent him to prison for 12 years at 17
View Date:2025-01-19 19:37:54
PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A Philadelphia man won’t be retried in a 2011 shooting that injured four people, including a 6-year-old girl, and sent him to prison for more than a decade at age 17, a prosecutor announced Monday.
A judge closed the case against C.J. Rice, now 30, months after a federal judge found the defense lawyer at his 2013 trial deficient and the evidence “slender.” Rice had been serving a 30- to 60-year prison term until he was released amid the federal court ruling late last year.
The case was formally dismissed Monday after District Attorney Larry Krasner decided not to retry it. While he said most of the 45 exonerations his office has championed have been more clearcut cases of innocence, he found a new look at the evidence in Rice’s case more nuanced.
“The case falls within that 15% or so (of exoneration cases) where we believe it’s murky,” Krasner said at a press conference where he was joined by defense lawyers who pushed back on that view.
The reversal hinged on a few key points. A surgeon testified that Rice could not have been the person seen running from the scene because Rice had been seriously injured in a shooting three weeks earlier that fractured his pelvis.
Rice was shot on Sept. 3, 2011, in what he described as a case of mistaken identity. His trial lawyer, now deceased, agreed to stipulate that one of the Sept. 25, 2011, shooting victims was a potential suspect in Rice’s shooting — giving prosecutors a motive — even though there was little evidence of that.
“The evidence of (his) guilt was slender. Only one of the four victims was able to identify him and she admitted that the last time she had seen (him) was at least four years before the shooting. No weapon was ever recovered,” U.S. Magistrate Judge Carol Sandra Moore Wells wrote in her October report.
Rice left prison in December, but did not attend Monday’s court hearing. His lawyers said during a news conference that the case echoes many wrongful convictions that involve faulty eyewitness identification, ineffective counsel and overreach by prosecutors.
Nilam Sanghvi, legal director of the Pennsylvania Innocence Project, said the crime should have been thoroughly investigated before trial, not years later.
“It takes courage to face the wrongs of the past,” she said, while adding “we can never really right them because we can’t restore the years lost to wrongful conviction — here, over a decade of C.J.’s life.”
veryGood! (89)
Related
- Investigators believe Wisconsin kayaker faked his own death before fleeing to eastern Europe
- EPA Gives Chicago Decades to Replace Lead Pipes, Leaving Communities at Risk
- Federal judge lets Iowa keep challenging voter rolls although naturalized citizens may be affected
- Health Risks Due to Climate Change Are Rising Dangerously, Lancet Report Concludes
- Cameron Brink set to make Sports Illustrated Swimsuit debut
- RFK Jr. says Trump would push to remove fluoride from drinking water. ‘It’s possible,’ Trump says
- As Ice Coverage of Lakes Decreases, Scientists Work to Understand What Happens Under Water in Winter
- Oklahoma small town police chief and entire police department resign with little explanation
- Stop smartphone distractions by creating a focus mode: Video tutorial
- Love Is Blind's Marissa George Debuts New Romance After Ramses Prashad Breakup
Ranking
- Angels sign Travis d'Arnaud: Former All-Star catcher gets multiyear contract in LA
- Could daylight saving time ever be permanent? Where it stands in the states
- Richard Moore executed in South Carolina after governor rejects clemency arguments
- CeeDee Lamb injury update: Cowboys WR exits vs. Falcons with shoulder injury
- Pistons' Tim Hardaway Jr. leaves in wheelchair after banging head on court
- Police in Michigan say 4 killed, 17 injured after semitruck crashes into vehicles stuck in traffic
- CeeDee Lamb injury update: Cowboys WR exits vs. Falcons with shoulder injury
- What is generative AI? Benefits, pitfalls and how to use it in your day-to-day.
Recommendation
-
Drone footage captures scope of damage, destruction from deadly Louisville explosion
-
Apple's AI update is here: What to know about Apple Intelligence, top features
-
Drake London injury update: Falcons WR suffers hip injury after catching TD vs. Cowboys
-
Mega Millions winning numbers for November 1 drawing: Jackpot rises to $303 million
-
One person is dead after a shooting at Tuskegee University
-
Takeaways from AP’s report on how immigration transformed a Minnesota farm town
-
Doctors left her in the dark about what to expect. Online, other women stepped in.
-
How Fracking Technology Could Drive a Clean-Energy Boom